Mafia - Day 6

[Joehan]

I've read the arguments and it seems CB has a stronger, better thought out argument. Edgar going outside the thread and telling/persuading people to lynch someone, I think this is very fishy behavior.

therefore, LYNCH: Edgar Davids

[Edgar Davids]

seeing as i'm probably gonna get lynched off here's my explanation for suspecting the people I do.

CircleBoy:

- Cautiousness throughout the game. Generally if you're cautious you have something to hide and you don't want to be spotted. Generally (obviously not always), recklessness is associated with town as the mafia wouldn't want to put themselves in the limelight in such a way, especially as they'd be lynching off townies.

- Discussion of the rules/roles rather than of posts in the game itself. Mafia don't want to tread on any toes so will play it safe and ask questions about the game itself early on. This is linked with filler posts.

- Decision to no lynch instantly, and ignore all other posts in the thread. No discussion benefits mafia as then no evidence can be gathered from day 1 posting. CB was making out as if lynching someone meant you couldn't change your lynch afterwards and that a person would definitely have to die.

- Ghost's buddying with CB. Ghost has looked very suspicious as well and he's been following what CB has been saying a lot.

- His constant reference to the other game. He kept on saying "he's done this before" etc, rather than commenting on the actual game being played.

- Rather than questioning the lynches on him, he just counter-lynched those people with the sole reason of "they lynched me".

- His defence stinks of desperation and he's clutching at straws. Rather than trying to infer as to why people lynched in groups, as they did, he simply said it was "suspicious" that they did. He didn't infer because he knew the reason why.

- He was after fap or aidan first as he knew given their playing styles they'd be easy to get lynched off but saw there was an opportunity to turn the bandwagon onto me, and did so very slyly.

Griffin:

- He hasn't actually contributed to the discussion in any way yet. All his posts have been filler.

- He's trying too hard to blend in and not arouse any suspicion. He's been incredibly cautious this game and not tried really hard to pick any sides.

- All his posts are questioning the rules/roles of the game, rather than analysing any posts/lynches made by any people.

Ghost:

- Very similar to the other two. He's been buddying with CB all game and just referencing other games rather than analysing this one.

- So many times he's posted "Mani knows what he's doing, he's done this before", rather than trying to question/analyse why I've actually done anything I've done.

- He's been very cautious in his lynching. He went for the safe option of going for Aidan as he's the town idiot in hope that others would follow suit. He saw that the bandwagon wasn't going so no lynched rather than lynched CB at the time when there was a bandwagon forming on CB.

[dora da gora]

lol didnt read

[CircleBoy]

- Cautiousness throughout the game. Generally if you're cautious you have something to hide and you don't want to be spotted. Generally (obviously not always), recklessness is associated with town as the mafia wouldn't want to put themselves in the limelight in such a way, especially as they'd be lynching off townies.

>I point you to game one in which I played the exact same opening and was town. A game in which you were mafia and killed me btw

- Discussion of the rules/roles rather than of posts in the game itself. Mafia don't want to tread on any toes so will play it safe and ask questions about the game itself early on. This is linked with filler posts.

>Don't even understand this one

- Decision to no lynch instantly, and ignore all other posts in the thread. No discussion benefits mafia as then no evidence can be gathered from day 1 posting. CB was making out as if lynching someone meant you couldn't change your lynch afterwards and that a person would definitely have to die.

>See first response, also pressuring on day 1 gives as much info to mafia as town. We could get into an argument about the best way to play mafia but then your argument would just be "CB is mafia because he plays sub optimaly"

- Ghost's buddying with CB. Ghost has looked very suspicious as well and he's been following what CB has been saying a lot.

>From what I've gathered ghost just likes that I'm actualy explaining my actions, which we sorely lacked game 1.

- His constant reference to the other game. He kept on saying "he's done this before" etc, rather than commenting on the actual game being played.

>He's dfone this before IS a comment on the current game, you need to be doing something in THIS game for me to even make this comment. Jesus edgar. It's not my fault you cant change up your playstyle.

- Rather than questioning the lynches on him, he just counter-lynched those people with the sole reason of "they lynched me".

>And I withdrew those lynches...I mean you said it earlier in this very post a lynch vote isnt final, then when thetime came for my real lynch (you) I gave reasons. It also amuses me that several people voted to lynch me with no stated reason but I'm the suspicious one when I counter lynch (and withdraw).

- His defence stinks of desperation and he's clutching at straws. Rather than trying to infer as to why people lynched in groups, as they did, he simply said it was "suspicious" that they did. He didn't infer because he knew the reason why.

>What am I meant to say edgar...nobody says anyhting in topic and then theres a cluster lynch vote on me. What am I meant to take from this other than that there has been some out of topic communication? How can I adress this communication when I am not privy to it? Who are literaly within the rules of the game given the ability to communicate out of topic? The mafia

- He was after fap or aidan first as he knew given their playing styles they'd be easy to get lynched off but saw there was an opportunity to turn the bandwagon onto me, and did so very slyly.

>So earlier on you say I counterlynched without thought and that was suspicious. But now you've ascribed reason to those lynches and made those reasons suspicious. Which is it edgar? Aidan isnt that suspicious imo, at least he justified his actions when he made them.

[CircleBoy]

Also while I cant adress the behaviour of anyone else I find it hilarious that the guy who cluster lynches with team gordon is saying people are suspicious for buddying with me.

[Griffin]

Blimey, how are you supposed to pick sides when you don't really know who is on which side, and I don't go around making wild accusations unless I am pretty sure I know what is going on. It's only the 2nd day yet we are supposed to have worked out who everyone is?

I have been analysing posts and behaviours, and I do have my suspects.

What about those that have not said a word yet? Or those that have posted only once or twice?

I contributed plenty in the chatbox by the way.

[Aaron]

My logic is....DOWN WITH #TEAMGORDON!

CB makes the most sense but I'm not sure if there's an ulterior motive to it...and him and Ghost are a tight knit bunch but those team gordon amigos are just bandwagoning....MAYBE IT'S ALL THEM? Who knows, who knows................dotdotdot

[Ghost]

Thank you Mani!

Finally someone makes a decent post giving reasons as to why they are suspicious. It's all I ever wanted from life, honestly. Now everyone take note and follow suit.

[noj]

Current lynch votes
CB (rolex, edgar, aidan, ovo, fap)
Edgar (momo, CB, soc, mick, joehan)
No lynch (ghost)

[OvoXo]

If there's equal number of votes for lynchying, do both get lynched?

[Griffin]

As others have pointed out, CB's arguments appear more logical, and he is being targeted by the Lynchie group.

Having pondered over this for quite some time, I keep coming back to the fact that the splinter group formed and seems to have somewhat isolated itself. Why? Are they all mafia? I don't know, but if Edgar is not the leader then he himself has been carefully manipulated to act as a mouthpiece.

I've also been considering the first day when arguments were raging between certain members, and I feel that something happened then that has set the tone for the resulting splinter group and there could well be others that appear to have distanced themselves from this group who are actually influencing their actions quite strongly.

I just don't trust this group.

Vote: Lynch Edgar Davids

[Edgar Davids]

I'm the watcher l0l

[Ghost]

Dunno. Edgar took time to write out a good defence for himself, whereas others may have just crumpled and given up(there was a point where I saw him mention that he couldn't be arsed in the chatbox, and I really did think he was mafia at that point) so I'm starting to think that maybe it isn't him and he's being genuine. Maybe one of the others are influencing him in some way, I'm not sure. Rolex & Fap did say that Edgar was telling them who to vote for, but if Edgar isn't the cop himself then who has been feeding him the information and can we really trust them?

My eyes are falling onto Ovo, he's been quite quiet recently in regards to lynching. Has he been the one feeding Edgar information? And is he truly the cop or is he mafia trying to get the lynchy crew to form a crusade for him to avoid the hammer coming down onto his own head?

[MoMo]

Find out next when the drama continues in the next episode of Feed Me Mafia!

[noj]

Day 2 has ended and the town chose to lynch Edgar Davids, who had the role of:

Spoiler: Show

Watcher

Night 2 has now begun and will last until Friday 20:00 or when all night actions have been received.

Barry failed to post again this game day so he has been replaced with Shockboy who has taken over his role.

Aaron you didn't vote so you have 1 warning.

[noj]

Fap was killed in the night, his role was:

Spoiler: Show

Townie

Day 3 has now begun and will last until Sunday 20:00.

[Aidan]

Think we all know whats going on here.

Idiots lynched mani

Lynch : CB

Ghost your next

[Mick]

Lynch: CircleBoy

Goin on the cop report and fap was lookin like he knew something about cb so probs why he was killed off

[CircleBoy]

If I was mafia killing fap would possibly be the stupidest thing I could do.

[CircleBoy]

Right. Mani being town does NOT make me mafia. Several of you thought mani was suspicious enough to vote to lynch him? Are all of you mafia? You can't all be mafia. I lynched mani for the same reasons you all did. I just argued the hardest because it was my neck on the line.

Now as for killing fap. He's been suspicious of me for a while so killing him is just about the most obvious and stupid thing I could do if I were mafia. I'm revising my earlier thoughts. It's clear the gordons aren't mafia (unless the remaining ones are) I think mani being lynched and fap being killed points to the mafia beaing afriad of the team gordon hivelynch.

I'm not saying its clear I'm not mafia. I'm just saying it's not as clear cut as it first appears. Mafia knew I'd be suspicious after manis death so they took the opportunity to take out another gordon and put the final nail in my coffin.